Disneyland is a unique gem among Disney’s properties, drawing in a predominantly local crowd who revel in the park’s magic throughout the year. Among these Disney enthusiasts are the elite members of Club 33, an exclusive private dining club nestled in New Orleans Square. Members of this illustrious club often enjoy perks such as watching guests from the balcony as they queue for iconic rides like Pirates of the Caribbean or the Haunted Mansion.

However, the magic can sometimes come at a hefty price. Scott and Diana Anderson, dedicated members of Club 33, cherished their access to this elite haven, visiting Disneyland up to 80 times a year. Their enjoyment was cut short in 2017 when Disney revoked their membership, alleging that Scott was intoxicated in the park. This turn of events led to a legal battle that drained the couple financially and emotionally. Despite spending around $400,000 in a fight to regain their membership, an Orange County jury upheld Disney’s decision on September 3, 2024, marking a bitter end to their club privileges.

During the trial, Scott Anderson’s lawyer argued that Disney mishandled the situation, citing a vestibular migraine, which can mimic intoxication symptoms, as the real issue. However, Disney’s representatives and security witnesses asserted that Anderson was indeed intoxicated, violating the strict rules that Club 33 members are expected to follow. Disney’s legal team emphasized that Mr. Anderson’s actions had regrettably cost his wife, Diana, her dream membership.

This verdict leaves a significant question for Disneyland enthusiasts: Did Disney rightfully revoke the Andersons’ membership, or was there an underlying medical condition misunderstood as intoxication? The saga highlights the stringent policies in place within Disney’s exclusive circles and sparks a broader discussion about fairness and due process.

Do you think the Andersons deserved to lose their Club 33 membership, or do you sympathize with their plight? Share your thoughts in the comments and let’s keep the conversation going.

Source: Inside the Magic